• Skip Navigation •

Trade Silver: Analyzing Trade Goods Desired by Native Americans

Grade Level: 8

Estimated duration of lesson: One Period (leading up to the French & Indian war)

The content standards:
* Topic Historical Thinking and Skills: Historical thinking begins with a clear sense of time – past, present and future – and becomes more precise as students progress. Historical thinking includes skills such as locating, researching, analyzing and interpreting primary and secondary sources so that students can begin to understand the relationships among events and draw conclusions.
o Content Statement1. Primary and secondary sources are used to examine events from multiple perspectives and to present and defend a position.
* Topic Human Systems: Human systems represent the settlement and structures created by people on Earth’s surface. The growth, distribution and movements of people are driving forces behind human and physical events. Geographers study patterns in culture and the changes that result from human processes, migrations and the diffusion of new cultural traits.
o Content Statement15. The movement of people, products and ideas resulted in new patterns of settlement and land use that influenced the political and economic development of the United States.

The Primary Sources Used

* Native American Image - Joseph Brant (Thayendanegea), 1743-1807

A summary of the lesson
Students will analyze both images of trade silver and/or practical pieces supplied by the teacher. Students will begin the lesson by looking at the different items, analyzing them, then, hypothesizing why Native Americans found value in such items, that most white Europeans felt were trivial. Then students will be asked to explain why seemingly worthless items hold value and importance to people.

Description of the Instructional Steps to Implement the Lesson

Show the trade silver or images to the class.
Ask - “What are these?”  - write responses on the board.
Share the Native American Image with the class and explain that the answer lies somewhere in the image.
Have the students in table groups complete the Artifact Analysis Worksheet. Split the table into two smaller groups, each completing one of the Artifact Analysis Worksheets.
Save the final questions relating to today’s culture…we’ll get to that at the very end!

Once students have completed the Artifact Analysis Worksheet have them have a guided discussion about why we find value in things today, using handout.

Why would Native American’s find value in things like trade silver?
To show relationships (connections)
Importance within the tribe
Trade items

Complete the object Analysis portion of the Artifact Analysis Worksheet asking about how does this compare to today’s society.  Are we that much different than Native Americans 300 years ago?

Worksheets or other materials for using the primary source(s). 
A post-assessment and its scoring guideline

The post assessment is based on the final two questions from the Artifact Analysis Worksheet; following the final step of the lesson.  Scoring is below.

List any materials needed by teachers 
* Trade Silver Pieces and/or images
Comics, baseball cards, or collectable erasers--or just the provided images.

List any materials needed by students
* Pencil
* Text

Created by Ethan Hamilton


Latest News!


For your participation in Connecting to the Past, you have earned Three Graduate Non-Degree Credit Semester Hours from the Ohio State University.

For an official record of those hours, you may request a transcript from Ohio State. Those credits will be posted after August 20, 2012.

To get a transcript, you must order it on-line.

Note: Only YOU can order a transcript. Entities that cannot order your transcript include: The History Teaching Institute, Tri-County Educational Service Center, the Ohio Historical Society, and the Connecting to the Past program

Before ordering a transcript, please read the Overview and proceed through the tabs, "Payment" "Authorization" and "Pricing." To order transcript, you will click on the "Start My Order" button on the upper right of the screen accessed at the link above. Note that your credit is being assigned in the Summer Semester 2012.


Document-based whole-class discussion is a classroom activity where students engage in the interpretation and reconciliation of multiple historical documents. Rather than a heated debate, the classroom dynamic resembles a deliberative seminar, where the teacher plays an active role in facilitating student participation.

You can download a detailed description, with handouts. Another teaching resource from your friends at teachinghistory.org

The APRIL NEWSLETTER is now availible! Click the link at left to Learn about:

The Connecting to the Past Quilt

Remember making a history-themed quilt square at the Orientation? Molly has put them all together and taken a picture.

Following the links:

on our eHistory site

ORIGINS: Current Events in Historical Perspective


Our August Issue:

cover image

Russia, America, and the Conspiratorial Worldview (by Stephen M. Norris)